Some people worry a lot about scooping. Scooping, for those not in the know, is a term in science that is borrowed from journalism, and refers to someone trying to beat someone else to publish a story. In the context of science, that might refer to someone initiating or rushing to complete a project so that they can be the first to document some phenomenon and presumably get all of the credit.
I wanted to begin by discussing what scooping is not. Scooping is not when someone else working on similar projects happens to publish before you. That is just science. Scooping is also not people working on similar problems, or even being inspired by your research to work on similar problems. That is also just how science works. Rather, scooping is specifically someone trying to monopolize credit for a result or idea by beating someone else to publication.
When is scooping a problem? In my little corner of biology, it happens most frequently in taxonomy, specifically when describing new species. I am aware of a case where some senior scientists got wind of a more junior scientist that was publishing a monograph on a group with several new species descriptions. The senior authors rushed out a species description of one of the species so that they could beat the junior author to the punch. The junior author still published the monograph, but obviously did not name the scooped new species. Outside of taxonomy, I think scooping tends to happen in molecular biology and related fields, where new discoveries might have commercial applications. The drama and controversy surrounding the origins and discovery of CRISPR is a great example of this.
So scooping can happen in our field, and if it happens to you, I could imagine that it might have negative impacts. But should you worry about scooping? I don’t think so, in most cases. First, it is very rare. Most people are focused on their own research, and can’t or won’t switch their research to follow your interests. Second, most of our work is incremental, and does not have major commercial implications. If the only thing you have going for your research is novelty, then you probably need to do a deeper dive to better situate your work in the field. We have heard a lot about a replication crisis in science for over a decade now, and so we should welcome folks working on similar questions in similar systems- this is how we understand the generality and applicability of our results. My expectation is that you could hand two scientists the same dataset, and two different papers would be written that would be productively complementary, rather than two identical copies. Finally, you also shouldn’t worry about scooping because in the long view of an entire career, a single paper is likely to be too terribly important, and even if it is, rarely is credit apportioned to a single paper or person for new ideas.
I also think that obsessing about scooping is not good for science. It makes folks paranoid about sharing ideas, methods, and data, which is antithetical to good science. Being paranoid about scooping puts the focus on single scientist (or group) and paper, rather than seeing how the work fits within the broader field. And even if someone scoops you, go ahead and publish your work. You will have something unique and important to say, and will still contribute to the work by establishing the generality (or lack thereof) of the research, which is exactly how science moves forward.
I wanted to begin by discussing what scooping is not. Scooping is not when someone else working on similar projects happens to publish before you. That is just science. Scooping is also not people working on similar problems, or even being inspired by your research to work on similar problems. That is also just how science works. Rather, scooping is specifically someone trying to monopolize credit for a result or idea by beating someone else to publication.
When is scooping a problem? In my little corner of biology, it happens most frequently in taxonomy, specifically when describing new species. I am aware of a case where some senior scientists got wind of a more junior scientist that was publishing a monograph on a group with several new species descriptions. The senior authors rushed out a species description of one of the species so that they could beat the junior author to the punch. The junior author still published the monograph, but obviously did not name the scooped new species. Outside of taxonomy, I think scooping tends to happen in molecular biology and related fields, where new discoveries might have commercial applications. The drama and controversy surrounding the origins and discovery of CRISPR is a great example of this.
So scooping can happen in our field, and if it happens to you, I could imagine that it might have negative impacts. But should you worry about scooping? I don’t think so, in most cases. First, it is very rare. Most people are focused on their own research, and can’t or won’t switch their research to follow your interests. Second, most of our work is incremental, and does not have major commercial implications. If the only thing you have going for your research is novelty, then you probably need to do a deeper dive to better situate your work in the field. We have heard a lot about a replication crisis in science for over a decade now, and so we should welcome folks working on similar questions in similar systems- this is how we understand the generality and applicability of our results. My expectation is that you could hand two scientists the same dataset, and two different papers would be written that would be productively complementary, rather than two identical copies. Finally, you also shouldn’t worry about scooping because in the long view of an entire career, a single paper is likely to be too terribly important, and even if it is, rarely is credit apportioned to a single paper or person for new ideas.
I also think that obsessing about scooping is not good for science. It makes folks paranoid about sharing ideas, methods, and data, which is antithetical to good science. Being paranoid about scooping puts the focus on single scientist (or group) and paper, rather than seeing how the work fits within the broader field. And even if someone scoops you, go ahead and publish your work. You will have something unique and important to say, and will still contribute to the work by establishing the generality (or lack thereof) of the research, which is exactly how science moves forward.
RSS Feed