I have been on many (over a dozen) search committees for tenure-track and non-tenure track and permanent jobs at a couple of different institutions. One of the challenges that I have seen repeatedly is the challenge of properly prioritizing research vs. teaching vs. service when evaluating candidate applications. I believe that the simple way to prioritize these different areas is to identify what is most important for a particular position, and then prioritize excellence in that area first. As an example, if we are hiring permanent teaching faculty, many of them will have done exciting research. However, research will not be part of their assignment, and so their research is not that relevant for that specific job. It might matter a little in a close call, but probably not even then. We should really try to pick the best candidates based upon teaching criteria, then within that smaller pool pick those with potential for research mentorship, or potential for excellent service within the department.
Let me expand this argument a little in the context of a tenure track position with research as part of the assignment. Most positions will get dozens to hundreds of applications, and some will have strengths in teaching while others will have strengths in research. I would argue that you should only consider candidates with research programs that you think are likely to get them tenure. This is because in my experience (both personal experience and discussions with many colleagues), at multiple institutions with different levels of research intensity, it is only the research aspect that can potentially result in a failure to be tenured. While teaching often matters, I have never seen it be the deciding factor in a tenure case. This will vary between jobs, and in practicality, if someone is bad at teaching, they probably also dislike teaching and may well leave prior to tenure and promotion. My experience is even at very teaching-focused institutions, if research is part of the assignment, research is where people fail to achieve tenure. Hence, if the position is at an institution where research is where people fail the tenure process, then it makes the most sense to make evidence of a sustainable and successful research program be the first cut as the committee narrows down the pool.
The previous paragraphs may convey the message that I don’t think teaching or service matters for tenure-track positions, which is far from the case. These are crucial parts of the job, and I would never vote to hire anyone who I thought was not a good teacher or would not contribute to departmental service. Once you have identified a pool of candidates that are likely to be competitive based upon their research program, you can then identify those candidates within that pool with the most impressive teaching experience and plans, and those that have the best and most exciting service. But if you change the order so that you pick based upon service first, or teaching first, for a position where research has to meet certain thresholds to get tenure, you are setting the successful applicant up for failure when they try to get tenure. In other words, identify the core responsibilities of the specific position, with a particular eye for tenure and promotion (or renewal of contract), and then prioritize candidates based upon the criteria that will matter most for consequential evaluations.
Let me expand this argument a little in the context of a tenure track position with research as part of the assignment. Most positions will get dozens to hundreds of applications, and some will have strengths in teaching while others will have strengths in research. I would argue that you should only consider candidates with research programs that you think are likely to get them tenure. This is because in my experience (both personal experience and discussions with many colleagues), at multiple institutions with different levels of research intensity, it is only the research aspect that can potentially result in a failure to be tenured. While teaching often matters, I have never seen it be the deciding factor in a tenure case. This will vary between jobs, and in practicality, if someone is bad at teaching, they probably also dislike teaching and may well leave prior to tenure and promotion. My experience is even at very teaching-focused institutions, if research is part of the assignment, research is where people fail to achieve tenure. Hence, if the position is at an institution where research is where people fail the tenure process, then it makes the most sense to make evidence of a sustainable and successful research program be the first cut as the committee narrows down the pool.
The previous paragraphs may convey the message that I don’t think teaching or service matters for tenure-track positions, which is far from the case. These are crucial parts of the job, and I would never vote to hire anyone who I thought was not a good teacher or would not contribute to departmental service. Once you have identified a pool of candidates that are likely to be competitive based upon their research program, you can then identify those candidates within that pool with the most impressive teaching experience and plans, and those that have the best and most exciting service. But if you change the order so that you pick based upon service first, or teaching first, for a position where research has to meet certain thresholds to get tenure, you are setting the successful applicant up for failure when they try to get tenure. In other words, identify the core responsibilities of the specific position, with a particular eye for tenure and promotion (or renewal of contract), and then prioritize candidates based upon the criteria that will matter most for consequential evaluations.
RSS Feed